Brokerage News

SERHANT Just Joined ARA. Here Is What the Association War Means for Your Recruiting

2026-11-12 8 min read By Coach Randy Byrd

SERHANT just joined the American Real Estate Association, and I want you to understand why that headline is a recruiting event for your team, not just a trade-press story.

On November 9, 2026, Ryan Serhant's brokerage, 2,000-plus agents across 20 states and Washington, D.C., became the latest major firm to align with ARA, the trade group that Compass agent Jason Haber and The Agency CEO Mauricio Umansky founded in January 2024 as a voluntary alternative to the National Association of Realtors. SERHANT agents get free ARA membership through 2027. They join Compass International Holdings, RE/MAX, Douglas Elliman, and The Agency in a group that has grown to roughly 20,000 members across all 50 states. HousingWire covered the announcement, and Real Estate News called it a major step forward for the association.

Read that the way I coach. The biggest names in this industry are now bundling association membership into what it means to belong to their company. That is not a footnote about dues. That is a recruiting arms race, and it is running through the one thing every licensed agent owns: their professional identity.

What ARA actually is

Let me give you the facts straight, because you cannot coach from rumor. ARA is a nonprofit trade association built by agents, for agents, and it runs on a simple premise: membership is a choice, not a requirement. It costs $20 a year, or $1,500 for a 10-year founding membership, and it focuses on advocacy, professional standards, education, and representation. It has been pushing "licensee-in-the-loop" AI legislation in statehouses, and unlike the traditional model, it does not mandate cooperation rules or commission structures. The New York Times framed it as the first real competition for NAR, and co-founder Jason Haber has said the old model was "too big to fail, until it failed." You can read the association's own framing on its site.

Now the timeline, because the pace is the story. Douglas Elliman signed on in September 2025, bringing roughly 6,600 agents. RE/MAX became ARA's first major franchise partner in June 2026, with every U.S. RE/MAX agent getting a free first-year membership. Compass International Holdings followed in late July 2026, covering its company-owned agents through 2027. And on November 9, SERHANT joined, covering its agents for 2026 and 2027.

The association war is a recruiting war

Here is what most agents will miss, and it is the part you should not. The brokerages are not joining ARA because they love trade associations. They are joining because association membership is now a recruiting perk, and the perks are escalating. RE/MAX pays for year one. Compass pays through 2027. SERHANT pays through 2027. When the biggest companies in the industry start covering a $20 membership as a headline benefit, they are not selling dues relief. They are selling belonging, and they are doing it publicly.

That is the shift you need to name out loud. For years, the recruiting conversation was about splits, leads, and brand. Now the giants are competing on who represents you, who stands for you, and who you belong to. That is a conversation about identity and advocacy, and it is happening in every market in the country. It is also the clearest sign yet that the industry is fragmenting into choices: brokerage choice, model choice, association choice. And every agent in your market is now weighing those choices out loud.

The question every agent is now asking

Here is the coaching part. The association story is not really about associations. It is a mirror held up to the agents in your market, and what they see in it is a question: who actually has my back?

Agents watched the mega-mergers, the commission lawsuits, the private-listing fights, and the recruiting slowdown, and they have been quietly asking who represents them in all of it. The ARA wave gives that question a name and a price tag. Some agents will join ARA. Some will stay with the traditional model. Most will not join anything new at all. But almost every one of them is now thinking about what their membership actually gets them, and that is a conversation you can have with any agent in your market this week without it feeling like a pitch.

That is the real estate recruiting lesson hiding in this news: agents are not deciding on logos anymore. They are deciding on who stands for them, and the association war is just the loudest version of that decision. If you want to know how to attract real estate agents to your team, start by understanding what they are really choosing.

The playbook: turn the association news into recruiting momentum

Here is my no-BS version of the week ahead.

1. Bring the news into your conversations. Send one message to your database that names what happened: SERHANT joined ARA, the giants are bundling membership, and here is what it means for an agent's career. Not a pitch. A straight read of the news. You will be the only leader in their inbox who explained it first.

2. Ask the question, not the pitch. When an agent brings up dues, NAR, or the association news, do not defend your company's position. Ask them what their membership actually gets them, and what they want it to get them. The agent who answers that question out loud has just told you what they are missing, and that is the conversation real estate recruiting is supposed to be.

3. Show them what belonging means on your team. The giants are selling association membership as the belonging benefit. You can beat that with something they cannot bundle: coaching, systems, culture, and a path upward. Bring an agent into your team meeting, show them your coaching calendar, let them watch how your leaders treat your agents. Belonging you can feel beats belonging you can invoice.

4. Publish your position. Write the post, record the video, send the note that names what the association war really means and what it does not. Agents search the news before they move, and the voice that explains the industry is the voice they trust when the decision comes. That is team leader coaching in action: earn the authority, and the agents come to you.

The straight Coach take

Here is the direct version, because that is how I coach. The association war is not a threat to your recruiting. It is an opening, because it has put the question every agent is already asking into the news: who actually has my back? The giants are answering with a $20 membership. You can answer with a system, a culture, and a leader who shows up. The agents who are ready to move are choosing on that answer right now, and the ones who are not moving yet are still reading.

I have been coaching performance for 13 years and leading an organization spanning 30 states and 5 countries, and I can tell you the teams that grow through industry noise are not the ones with the biggest perk list. They are the ones who can take any headline, translate it into an agent's personal decision, and be the obvious answer when the agent asks who is on their side. The association story is just the latest headline. The question it asks is permanent.

Your move

Stop watching the association war from the sidelines. It is a recruiting conversation happening in every market, and the leaders who name it, explain it, and show up with something better will be the ones agents call when they are ready to move. The question is not whether the industry will keep changing. The question is whether you will be the leader agents find when they go looking.

If you are ready to build the system that attracts agents to your team while the industry reshuffles, book a 10-minute call with Coach Randy Byrd and bring your numbers. We will look at your recruiting message, your offer, and your next twelve months, and map exactly what an attraction engine looks like for your team. The association war is just the latest headline. Your system is the answer. Book your 10-minute call here.

Coach Randy Byrd

Coach Randy Byrd

Team Leader, Speaker, and Performance Coach with eXp Realty. 1,200+ agents across 30 states and 5 countries. 13 years as a performance coach. Founder of Attract Boss Coaching.

Book a Strategy Call

Ready to put these strategies to work?

Book a free 10-minute call with Coach Byrd and get personalized guidance for your recruiting goals.

Book a Strategy Call
Someone just bought PARTNER! 🔥